Prevalence and Trends in Global Retractions Explored Through a Topic Lens
By: Zhengyi Zhou , Ying Lou , Zhesi Shen and more
Potential Business Impact:
Finds fake science papers to keep real science honest.
Scientific publications form the cornerstone of innovation and have maintained a stable growth trend over the years. However, in recent years, there has been a significant surge in retractions, driven largely by the proliferation of low-quality and fraudulent papers. This study aims to examine retractions and their evolving trends through a topic lens. Our analysis of global retraction data reveals that the numbers of retraction have remained alarmingly high in recent years, with the growth rate of retracted papers significantly outpacing that of overall global publications. While retractions are observed across various fields, their distribution is not uniform. In disciplines characterized by high retraction rates, certain topics may only encounter minor issues, whereas in fields with lower retraction rates, some topics can experience substantial challenges. Moreover, an unexpected surge in publications has been observed in specific topics that also display abnormally high retraction rates. This study underscores several indicators that can assist the scientific community in pinpointing key fields that require rigorous scrutiny for potential low-quality and fraudulent research. Ultimately, our findings could serve as a benchmark for examining scientific integrity across diverse topics and offer crucial insights for developing tailored governance policies to enhance research integrity in each field.
Similar Papers
The State of Papers, Retractions, and Preprints: Evidence from the CrossRef Database (2004-2024)
Digital Libraries
Science papers grow steadily, not by big events.
Are Widely Known Findings Easier to Retract?
Digital Libraries
Makes bad science easier to remove.
When Collaborative Maintenance Falls Short: The Persistence of Retracted Papers on Wikipedia
Human-Computer Interaction
Fixes Wikipedia's wrong science links.